Homeowners Insurance vs. Pet Insurance: Understanding Your Options and Choosing the Right Coverage

If you’ve ever rushed to the emergency vet or worried about your dog biting a neighbor, you’re not alone. Pets are family — and like any loved one, they can bring joy, messes, and surprise expenses. From chewed-up furniture to unexpected surgery or even a liability claim, pet-related costs can add up fast. That’s where insurance comes in—but not all policies cover the same risks.

In this post, we’ll break down how homeowners insurance and pet insurance work, what they cover, and how they differ. You’ll learn about liability risks, vet costs, coverage options, and tips to protect both your wallet and your furry companion.

How Homeowners Insurance Protects You When You Have Pets

Understanding Liability and Why It Matters

At its core, homeowners insurance is designed to protect you from financial disaster when the unexpected happens—everything from a burst pipe to a kitchen fire. A lesser‑known yet key component is liability coverage: the part of your policy that pays medical bills and legal expenses if someone is injured on your property or if your pet injures someone. In a country where millions of dogs live in close quarters with neighbors and delivery drivers, this coverage is essential.

The Scale of Liability Risk

Dog bites and other animal‑related injuries aren’t just scary; they’re expensive. The Insurance Information Institute reports that the average liability claim for dog bites and other dog‑related injuries was about $58,500 in 2023.

Most homeowners policies include liability limits somewhere between $100,000 and $500,000, sufficient for minor incidents but quickly exhausted by severe injuries. Once your limit is reached, you must pay any additional amount personally, which is why some pet owners opt for umbrella policies that extend liability coverage by millions of dollars.

These numbers aren’t theoretical. Consider the real‑life cases reported by Hopkins Law Firm in South Carolina: a delivery driver was bitten by a homeowner’s dog while dropping off a package. The homeowner’s insurance covered $50,000 in medical bills and lost wages. In another case, a man bitten by his neighbor’s dog initially had his claim denied due to breed restrictions, but legal negotiations resulted in a $75,000 settlement. These examples show how a single incident can generate tens of thousands of dollars in liability, and how homeowners insurance steps in to cover those costs.

Liability Coverage Follows Your Dog

A common misconception is that liability coverage only applies on your property. In reality, liability insurance follows your dog almost anywhere: at the park, on a walk, even in another state. If you’re found legally responsible for your dog biting someone or knocking them over at a playground, your homeowners policy generally responds. The coverage isn’t tied to your address; it’s tied to your responsibility for your pet’s actions.

Coverage Isn’t for Your Own Family

It’s important to understand who is covered. Homeowners liability protects you against injuries to other people—not injuries to you or members of your household. If your dog bites your child or partner, your liability coverage will not pay those medical bills; your family would rely on personal health insurance. This distinction underscores why pet insurance is valuable (more on that later).

Breed Restrictions, State Laws & Extra Coverage Options

While your homeowners policy likely offers liability protection, not all dogs are viewed the same. Insurers assess risk based on breed, behavior, and past incidents. Unfortunately, some breeds have reputations for causing severe bites, which can make obtaining coverage more complicated.

Commonly Excluded Breeds

Insurance companies often maintain a “restricted” or “dangerous” dog list. Breeds frequently excluded or subject to higher premiums include:

• Pit bulls & Staffordshire terriers
• Rottweilers
• Doberman pinschers
• German shepherds
• Siberian & Alaskan huskies
• Wolf hybrids
• Mastiffs and large guardian breeds (e.g., Great Danes, Akitas, Presa Canarios).

These lists vary between insurers. Some are based strictly on breed, while others consider individual temperament or training. A single bite incident, even for a historically “safe” breed, can lead an insurer to drop coverage or increase premiums.

What to Do If Your Dog Is Excluded

Do not assume your insurance company knows you have a dog. When you apply for a policy or add a pet to your household, you must inform your insurer. If you fail to disclose the presence of your pet—especially one considered higher risk—and your dog injures someone, the insurer may deny the claim. Be honest about your pet’s breed, age, and bite history so that coverage is clear before something happens.

If your dog is on a restricted list or has a bite history, don’t panic. There are still ways to protect yourself.

• Shop around: Some insurers, such as State Farm, evaluate dogs based on bite history rather than breed. Switching providers may solve the problem.
• Purchase an umbrella policy: Umbrella insurance adds extra liability coverage beyond your standard homeowners limit. It’s relatively inexpensive and can be tailored to cover pet‑related incidents.
• Look into canine liability insurance: These standalone policies cover damages caused by your dog, including bites and property damage. Unlike homeowners liability, which might exclude damage to your own items, a dedicated canine liability policy can cover a broader range of incidents.

By understanding breed restrictions and exploring your options, you can ensure you and your pet remain covered—even if your dog is a breed some insurers view as higher risk.

Your Property, Personal Belongings & Medical Payments

Homeowners insurance covers more than liability. It protects your home’s structure and personal belongings against perils like fire, theft, and certain weather events. However, there are limitations when it comes to pet‑related damage and medical payments.

Damage to Your Own Property Is Not Covered

If your dog chews your couch or scratches the hardwood floors, your homeowners policy won’t reimburse you. The policy’s property coverage is designed to repair or replace your home and belongings when damage is caused by covered perils (like fire or vandalism)—not when it’s caused by your own pet. Liability coverage also doesn’t help here because it compensates others, not the policyholder, for losses.

Medical Payments Coverage

Most homeowners policies include medical payments to others coverage, which pay small medical bills for people injured on your property, regardless of who is at fault. Limits are usually modest—between $1,000 and $5,000. This coverage is intended for minor injuries, such as a guest tripping on your steps, and won’t apply to your household members or your pets. For more significant injuries, you’d rely on liability coverage.

What Affects the Cost of Pet Insurance?

Pet insurance costs vary based on several factors:

Type of coverage – Basic accident-only plans are more affordable and cover emergencies like broken bones, poison ingestion, or injuries. More comprehensive accident-and-illness plans also cover things like cancer treatment, chronic conditions, infections, and hereditary issues.

Coverage limits – Some plans have annual payout limits, while others offer unlimited coverage. Plans with higher or unlimited limits generally come with higher premiums, but they also offer more protection in case of serious health problems.

Your pet’s age and breed – Younger pets typically cost less to insure, while older pets may have higher premiums due to increased health risks. Some breeds known for medical issues can also be more expensive to cover.

Your location – Veterinary care costs vary depending on where you live. Urban areas or regions with higher living costs tend to have more expensive premiums.

Customizable options – Most providers let you choose your reimbursement percentage (commonly 70%, 80%, or 90%) and deductible amount. Choosing a higher deductible or lower reimbursement rate can reduce your monthly premium—but you’ll pay more out of pocket when care is needed.

Understanding these factors helps you choose a plan that fits your needs and budget. Whether you’re looking for basic emergency coverage or full peace of mind for every vet visit, there’s a policy out there that can help protect your finances while keeping your pet healthy.

What Does Pet Insurance Cover?

Pet insurance generally reimburses a percentage of “covered” veterinary expenses. Coverage often includes:

• Accidents: Foreign‑object removal, broken bones, toxic ingestion, cuts, lacerations, and bite wounds.
• Illnesses: Digestive problems, ear infections, urinary‑tract issues, allergies, diabetes, and cancer.
• Chronic and hereditary conditions: Hip dysplasia, arthritis, heart disease, knee problems, spinal issues, and hereditary conditions like intervertebral disc disease.
• Diagnostics & surgeries: X‑rays, MRIs, bloodwork, hospitalization, surgery, and sometimes physical therapy and rehab.
• Medications & behavioral therapy: Prescription medications for infections or chronic diseases, plus behavioral support for issues like anxiety or destructive chewing.
• Alternative therapies: Acupuncture, chiropractic care, hydrotherapy, and other complementary treatments.
• Dental care: Treatment for gum disease, gingivitis, or periodontal issues. Some plans require add‑ons for dental work.
• Wellness add‑ons (optional): Routine checkups, vaccinations, flea/tick and heartworm prevention, dental cleanings, and spay/neuter surgery.

Common exclusions include pre‑existing conditions, elective procedures (like cosmetic surgeries), breeding and pregnancy costs, and routine care unless you buy a wellness add‑on. Some insurers will cover curable pre‑existing conditions after a symptom‑free period, but chronic conditions diagnosed before coverage starts are usually not reimbursed.

How to Choose the Right Pet Insurance Policy

Choosing a policy isn’t just about finding the lowest premium; it’s about balancing affordability with protection. Here’s what to look for when comparing plans:

Reimbursement Percentage – Many policies reimburse a percentage of eligible expenses after you meet your deductible. Common options are 70%, 80% and 90%. A higher reimbursement rate means the insurer pays more of the vet bill, but your premium will be higher. If you’re comfortable paying a larger share out‑of‑pocket, choosing 70% or 80% can lower your monthly cost.

Deductible (Annual vs. Per‑Incident) – A deductible is the amount you pay before your insurance starts reimbursing. It might be an annual deductible (you pay once per year) or per‑incident (you pay for each new condition or accident). Higher deductibles reduce your monthly premium but increase your out‑of‑pocket costs when a claim occurs. Balance the deductible with your budget: if you have savings set aside, a higher deductible may be fine; if not, choose a lower one.

Annual Coverage Limit – Insurance policies often cap the total payout per year. Limits generally range from $5,000 to unlimited. A lower limit reduces your premium but may leave you short if your pet requires multiple expensive treatments in one year. An unlimited plan costs more but offers peace of mind that you won’t hit a cap.

Wellness & Preventive Care Add‑Ons – Most accident‑and‑illness plans don’t cover routine care like vaccinations, parasite prevention or dental cleanings. Many insurers sell wellness riders that reimburse these predictable expenses. Adding a wellness plan raises your premium but can level out your pet‑care budget, especially if you prioritize regular checkups.

Waiting Periods – Every policy has waiting periods—time frames after you purchase the policy during which certain coverage isn’t effective. Accident waiting periods are often two days to two weeks; illness waiting periods can be 14 to 30 days, and orthopedic conditions may have even longer waiting periods. Read the fine print to avoid surprises.

Compare Multiple Quotes – Pet insurance isn’t one‑size‑fits‑all. Premiums vary significantly by insurer, location, and coverage options. To find the right plan, compare quotes from at least three providers. Look beyond price: examine reimbursement rates, deductibles, annual limits, exclusions, and customer reviews.

Take Advantage of Multi‑Pet & Bundling Discounts – If you own multiple pets, many insurers offer discounts for adding more animals to a single policy. Some companies also discount premiums when you bundle pet insurance with home or auto insurance. Ask your current insurer if bundling is an option.

6 Tips for Preventing Dog Bites & Lowering Insurance Risk

Beyond insurance, responsible pet ownership plays a huge role in preventing injuries and keeping premiums manageable. Here’s how you can reduce the risk of a bite incident:

#1 – Spay or Neuter Your Dog – Research shows that dogs who aren’t spayed or neutered are about three times more likely to bite than those that have been. Sterilization reduces hormonal aggression and roaming behavior, making your dog calmer and less likely to lash out.

#2 – Early Training & Socialization – Introduce your dog to a variety of people, animals, and environments from an early age. Enroll in positive‑reinforcement training classes and teach children how to safely interact with dogs (e.g., no hard hugging or pulling tails). A well‑socialized dog is less likely to be fearful or aggressive.

#3 – Avoid Rough Play – Wrestling, play‑fighting and tug‑of‑war can blur boundaries for your dog. While these games might seem harmless, they can encourage nipping or biting. Instead, focus on obedience training and games that reward calm behavior.

#4 – Secure Your Environment – Always leash your dog in public and ensure your yard is safely fenced, with gates that latch securely. When service workers or guests arrive, put your dog in another room until everyone is settled. A secure environment prevents unexpected interactions that could lead to a bite.

#5 – Address Warning Signs – A growl, a nip or even “resource guarding” (protecting food or toys) shouldn’t be ignored. Consult a veterinarian, certified trainer, or behaviorist if your dog shows signs of aggression. Early intervention can prevent a one‑time incident from becoming a pattern.

#6 – Make Your Dog Part of the Family – Dogs chained outside or isolated in a yard are more likely to become territorial and bite. Spend time with your dog, ensure they get exercise and mental stimulation, and involve them in family life. A happy, healthy dog is less likely to act out.

Adopting these practices not only keeps people safe but encourages insurers to view your dog more favorably. Demonstrating responsible ownership may help you secure coverage and prevent premium spikes due to claims.

Final Thoughts

Homeowners insurance and pet insurance are two sides of the same coin. One protects others from your dog; the other protects you from your pet’s medical expenses. Without liability coverage, a single bite or knock‑over incident can result in tens of thousands of dollars in medical bills and legal fees.

By understanding how these two forms of coverage work together, being honest with your insurer, and practicing responsible pet ownership, you’ll create a safety net that protects your family, your guests, and your four‑legged friend. Because at the end of the day, the goal isn’t just to avoid financial pain, it’s to enjoy life with your pet, secure in the knowledge that you’re prepared for whatever comes next.

Need to learn more about off-premises insurance?

Our agents are ready to help, so contact us to learn how we can customize your insurance policies to meet your needs.

*Disclaimer: We offer content for informational purposes; Co-operative Insurance Companies may not provide all the services or products listed here. Please get in touch with your local agent to learn how we can help with your insurance needs.

Sources

Bankrate. Pets and renters insurance: Why you need it. https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/homeowners-insurance/pets-and-renters-insurance/

Forbes. How Much Does Pet Insurance Cost? (2025). https://www.forbes.com/advisor/pet-insurance/pet-insurance-cost

MSPCA. Home Insurance and Pets. https://www.mspca.org/pet_resources/home-insurance-and-pets/

Nerd Wallet. Does Homeowners Insurance Cover Dog Bites? https://www.nerdwallet.com/article/insurance/homeowners-insurance-cover-dog-bites

Progressive. Is your homeowners insurance dog-friendly? https://www.progressive.com/answers/dog-friendly-homeowners-insurance/

Quicken Loans. A Guide To Understanding Homeowners Insurance And Pets.https://www.quickenloans.com/learn/homeowners-insurance-and-dogs